Once again the rise of gas prices brings forth a stream of invective from bleeding-pump conservatives. The same people who think that homeless shelters are a waste of money are now screaming for government help because their trips to the mall cost more. Of course, they don't say they are asking for a subsidy. Instead, they will claim that the government should cut its 'unfair' taxes on gasoline (federally, 10c per liter plus 7% GST). Frankly the taxes on gas have not changed in decades, and a directed tax cut like this is the same as a subsidy.
Today's broadcast of the CBC program
Cross Country Checkup on was filled with sob stories from people demanding that the government fix the high price of gasoline: truckers, business professors, and rural dwellers. Spare us the sob stories please. If you live in the country and work in the city, you made a bad choice. Find another job or move closer to work. It's not the government's fault. If you own a business and your costs are up, raise your prices or find another business. It's not the government's fault. If you live in the city and bought an SUV, you made a bad choice. It's not the government's fault.
A common theme on the program tonight was the 'high costs of gas' compared to the U.S. Why not compare our gas prices to other countries, nearly all of which have higher gas prices? Interesting that in the United States they have the same debate. The debate simply shifts - gas price complainers will complain that the taxes in their state are
higher than other states.For a refreshing counterpoint, the Edmonton Journal has a
clear-thinking article on high gas prices from Paula Simons. Says Simons:
If you don't like paying so much for gasoline, well, don't use so much.
Take the bus or LRT to work more often. Car-pool. Ride your bike or walk to the
store. Instead of using the drive-thru lane at the bank or Tim Hortons or
Wendy's, just park and go inside.[...]
So much of our economy is predicated on cheap fuel. It's been our invisible
subsidy for decades. But we've crashed head-on into a rude new reality, one we
can't just curse away. We won't find a long-term solution to high gasoline
prices in a tax cut or a government cheque.
Amen to that. Wonder if Stephen Harper reads the Edmonton Journal?